NBC’s new firefighting rescue drama Chicago Fire premiered last night, and it’s as about as terrible as you’d expect a show that markets itself by putting its entire cast in sweaty soot-stained undershirts to be.
It looks more like a poster for Magic Mike 2: Firehall Strippers.
This show is a giant pile of uninspired formulaic drivel from start to finish, and is more inaccurate about firefighting and emergency response than the marine biologist scientific advisors were for Syfy’s Sharktopus.
Still more believable than Abercrombie & Fitch models in fire helmets.
Here are 5 reasons Chicago Fire is an unbelievably stupid show:
1) TRAUMATIZED ALPHA MALE FIREFIGHTERS
The main two characters on the show are played by some wooden meathead and the Australian doctor from House M.D. whose stupid fake Chicago accent is more phony than Chris Brown posing with puppies.
Still a petulant woman-beating scumbag piece of shit.
Naturally, the rift between these two stoic chodes begins when one of their teammates gets killed and they each blame each other.
This tension is also heightened by the fact that the meathead runs the rescue squad and the guy from House M.D. — GASP! – commands the fire truck. I mean, how could anyone possibly expect two people with almost the exact same job except for a slight variation to get along?
I’ll take 2nd hand smoke as reason why these two hate one another before douchebag pea-cocking.
2) HIDING MEDICAL CONDITIONS
Early in the pilot episode, Meathead McStogie sneaks off by himself in the firehall, injects himself with cortisone or some kind of steroid, and then makes a big dramatic production out of clenching a fist so even the dumbest of viewers could connect the dots.
Now setting aside the ridiculousness of the guy acting like a junkie by locking himself in a bathroom stall to shoot up, the writers are literally trying to mine drama out of the stupidest of plot lines. Oh no, Meathead McStogie has some kind of chronic arthritis? Big f**king deal!
All he has to do is take advantage of his tremendous firefighter benefits and see a doctor for first rate medical care, not pretend he’s goddamn Ewan McGregor in Trainspotting.
Even if in future episodes they try to justify that self-medicating is his only way to keep from being forced out of rescue and into a desk job, by keeping such a debilitating condition a secret he’s still potentially risking the lives of co-workers and civilians if his hand gimps up on a call.
Also, those toned biceps are gonna shrink if he can’t do curls anymore.
3) HOT LESBIAN PARAMEDICS
There are lots of female paramedics. Some of them are even lesbians. But you know what none of them are? Crazy hot bikini models who slink around firehalls in tight undershirts flaunting big bouncy breasts.
If I’m in an accident and see a woman like this, I’m going to heaven, not a hospital.
4) THE ROOKIE
I’m so sick of “the rookie” being part of an ensemble rescue drama. I mean, come on, it’s been done to death. Carter from ER, the young cop from Third Watch, the probie from Rescue Me – hell, even the awesome biker show Sons Of Anarchy is guilty of playing the rookie card with their “prospects.”
However, they are a bit more lax on fitness requirements.
The rookie on Chicago Fire comes off as a particularly obtuse boner. His character exists solely as a clunky vehicle for other characters to spew excessive exposition about firefighting and emergency response, and the scene where he’s duped by his co-workers to hit on the lesbian paramedic is downright cringeworthy.
It’s like he’s squeezing a pickle between his buttcheeks. And liking it.
5) THEY’RE TERRIBLE AT THEIR JOBS
I happen to have a lot of firefighter friends. And you know what they all have in common? They’re not dead. None of them have nearly died dozens of times, none of them have been put into critical condition from falling debris during a fire, and none of them have fallen through a burning floor to their death.
Why? Because they’re well-trained and not retarded. The morons on Chicago Fire, however, are about as effective at firefighting and rescue as a ten-year-old playing dress up with a garden hose in his backyard.
“My inflatable axe will save you!”
Over the course of a single episode, one firefighter dies during a fire, another is knocked unconscious in a burning building, a third is gravely injured and put in life-threatening condition, and the damn rescue squad almost kills a little girl by accidentally stabbing her in the heart with a giant needle.
These shitheads are absolutely terrible at their jobs, and if they actually were protecting city streets in real life, then I’m pretty sure the entire city of Chicago would burn to the ground in about three weeks.
Because apparently all it takes to be a hero is a wife-beater and suspenders.


The show sucks.. end of story… The firefighters without their packs would die in a heartbeat.. The amount of toxic fumes/Carbon Monoxide.. and of course the heat alone on the lungs would be the end… Do not even get me started on the Paramedics treatment… End it now and bring back Hill Street Blues!!! OMG TV is dyiing
Hey Medic,
Thanks for your feedback!
I could not agree more with regards to Chicago Fire. What garbage! I guess the producers figured they couldn’t get close ups of chiseled jaw lines against the backdrop of flames if they were properly equipped so why not just toss that pesky life saving equipment altogether?
Here’s hoping this ridiculous farce gets cancelled soon!
Cheers,
Storm
P.S. If it weren’t for a few brilliant bright spots like Breaking Bad and Parks and Recreation I would whole-heartedly agree that TV is dying!
I totally agree. Sorry Dick Wolf, but this show sucks. The plot is so transparent & the characters are so stereotypically blah. I cant wait until its canceled so my wednesday at 10 timeslot will no longer suck.
Hey Ken,
Glad to hear I’m not the only one who thinks Dick Wolf just phoned this one in!
I watched my first and last episode of this series today. I am a former EMT and volunteer Fireman and was appalled at how inaccurate and wreckless these supposed professionals were from start to finish.
This show is an embarrasment and needs to be cancelled.
Hey Hoats,
Thanks for your feedback. It’s nice to hear from a professional emergency responder like yourself that this show is as ridiculous as it seems.
Here’s hoping Dick Wolf retires already!
Cheers,
Storm
so freaking stupid! what an insult to EMTS, Paramedics and Firefighters!! as a EMT this show is embarrassing! who comes up with this crap?
Hey Holly,
I’m right there with you. Veteran TV producer Dick Wolf is behind this pile, and he is basically taking a crap all over whatever street cred he had earned from his other respected dramas like Law & Order and Law & Order SVU by attaching his name to Chicago Fire.
Best new show this year. That’s why it just got orders for 2 more episodes this season. Guess you are all wrong haha
If only there were a correlation between shows staying on the air and quality programming, Jen!
Totally agree. Read my post.
Yikes what an incredibly cynical article….personally I really enjoy the show, and no its not because theyre all “so hot”. And I guess I would be more bothered by the ‘innaccuracies’ of the show if, you know, it was a documentary. But it’s not. It’s just a show meant to entertain people and I feel that it does that very well. But hey that’s just my opinion, and I’m no one. (I also feel you should give a show more than just one episode to see if it’s any good or not)
Hey Patsy,
Thanks for the feedback. I’m glad you found a show you enjoy, despite the fact I find Chicago Fire to be a detestable and idiotic pile that represents everything that’s wrong with TV industry.
One episode of this show’s melodramatic bullshit was all I could stomach. Also, I disagree with you about needing to give a show a few episodes — some are so fundamentally flawed a single episode is enough to know it’s not worth your time.
Cheers,
Storm
I’m sorry you all have negative thoughts about this show. BUT this show is by far the BEST show I’ve seen in a few years. Finally i can sit and enjoy to watch a show with my family. I’m sick and tired of all these Idiotic Reality shows and making stupid people become famous from them. No way are my children watching them. Role Models, ha ha definitely NOT. It’s time we finally have a positive show. Do all firefighters do this, No. But we can at least respect them more knowing they do risk their lives. Thank you Michael Brandt and Derek Haas. FINALLY.
Hey Minerva,
Thanks for your feedback. I’m happy you found a show you enjoy and find satisfying, even though I personally find it pretty insipid and lame. I am an Arrested Development and Breaking Bad junkie myself and there’s no one in the world that could talk me out of loving those shows so to each their own.
Nevertheless, despite my distaste for Chicago Fire I would rather watch ten seasons of that show than your typical pointless, exploitative and brain-rotting reality show (E!’s The Soup not withstanding because Joel McHale is the man).
Cheers,
Storm